7 States Where Independents Can Make the Biggest Impact in 2024

As the 2024 elections approach, the American political landscape is witnessing a noticeable shift towards independent voters and candidates. In many states, voters who identify as independent or unaffiliated now outnumber registered voters from either establishment party.

Join us as we analyze which states independents are poised to make the most significant impact in this year, focusing on areas with a high number of unaffiliated voters, key swing states, and locations where many candidates traditionally run unopposed.

The Factors That Prime States for Independent Representation

In an era when partisan divides are deepening, independents play an important role in determining electoral outcomes. Unfortunately, this isn’t always translating to votes. According to Reuters, 53% of independents sat out the 2020 elections, compared to 20% of Democrats and 23% of Republicans. 

Part of the problem is that voters in general feel that their vote doesn’t matter. But facts on the ground demonstrate that simply isn’t true. 

Before we dive into which states are most primed for an independent revolution, let’s take a look at the factors that could make such a transition from the status quo more likely:

1. High Number of Independent Voters: States with a large proportion of registered independents or voters who do not align strictly with the major political parties are prime locations for independent representation. These voters are more open to supporting candidates who are not bound by party ideologies.

2. Discontent with the Major Parties: Locations where there is significant public dissatisfaction with the performance or policies of the existing major parties can see a rise in independent candidates. Disillusionment drives voters to seek alternatives that they feel better represent their interests and concerns.

3. Flexible Voting Systems: States that use voting systems such as ranked choice voting (RCV) or nonpartisan blanket primaries are more conducive to independent candidates. These systems allow voters to express their preferences more freely without the strategic constraints often imposed by the traditional first-past-the-post system.

4. Demographic and Cultural Diversity: Areas with diverse populations in terms of ethnicity, economic status, and cultural backgrounds may find that traditional party platforms do not adequately address their varied interests and needs. This diversity can lead to a higher demand for independent candidates who offer more tailored and inclusive policies.

5. Effective Campaigns and Grassroots Support: Independent candidates who run strong, well-organized campaigns and can mobilize grassroots support are more likely to succeed. Locations with active civic engagement and high community involvement provide fertile ground for such campaigns.

6. Electoral Reforms and Advocacy: Locations where there is active advocacy for electoral reform, such as movements to end gerrymandering or to implement campaign finance reform, can also become hotbeds for independent politics. Reform-minded voters often support independents as champions of these causes.

7. History of Independent Successes: Regions with a history of electing independents may be more open to doing so again. Success breeds credibility, making it easier for new independent candidates to gain traction.

8. Media Coverage and Public Awareness: States where the media are open to covering independent candidates and where there is higher public awareness and education about the role and potential of independents see higher success rates for such candidates.

9. Political Transition Periods: During periods of political upheaval or major shifts, such as after a scandal or a major political realignment, independents can emerge as viable alternatives to the status quo, capitalizing on the public's desire for change.

10. Strategic Collaborations: Independent candidates who can effectively collaborate with various minor parties, community groups, and other non-traditional political movements stand a better chance of consolidating support against the major-party candidates.

A state or location that shows one or more of these characteristics is likely to be more receptive to independent candidates. These environments provide a strategic opportunity for independents to make a significant impact by offering alternatives to voters who are looking for new voices and approaches in their political representation.

With a high rate of independent voters and candidates in the United States, the independent movement is poised to make a larger impact on the 2024 elections than probably any other election in living memory. However, some states are better placed than others to usher in an unprecedented wave of independent influence. 

7 States Where Independents Are Poised to Make an Impact in 2024

Colorado: A Swing State With a Strong Independent Streak

Colorado stands out as a critical swing state with a robust independent voter base. Nearly half of Colorado’s electorate is registered as unaffiliated, making them the largest voting bloc in the state.

Their influence was apparent in recent elections where they played a pivotal role in deciding between Democratic and Republican candidates in tightly contested races. As the state continues to balance its liberal urban areas with conservative rural regions, the independent voters are key arbiters who can potentially swing the state in either direction. 

Maine: The Power of Ranked Choice Voting

Maine’s adoption of ranked choice voting has revolutionized its electoral process, providing a unique advantage to independent candidates who might not otherwise stand out in a traditional voting system. This method allows voters to rank candidates by preference, reducing the likelihood of “wasting” votes on independents and third-party candidates. 

The presence of Senator Angus King, an independent, highlights the state’s openness to non-partisan candidates. Maine’s independents are a critical audience in both presidential and congressional races, capable of tipping the scales in close contests.

Arizona: A New Battleground State

Even a few short years ago, few would have thought of Arizona as a place where the independent movement could thrive. However, Arizona has recently transformed into a battleground state, with independents comprising just under 1.5 million members of the electorate. Their impact was palpable in the 2020 presidential election and the 2022 midterm elections, where the margins of victory were slim. 

In addition to legislative acts that are increasingly unpopular with Arizona voters, independents in Arizona are also becoming younger and more diverse. This reflects broader demographic shifts that could influence future political trends. As both major parties vie for their support, independents are likely to be the deciding factor in whether Arizona leans blue, red, or independent in 2024.

Minnesota: The Growing Independent Movement

In Minnesota, the independence of the electorate is on the rise, with a significant portion of the population showing a tendency to vote outside the traditional party lines. 

This state has a history of supporting third-party candidates, such as former Governor Jesse Ventura. As political dissatisfaction with the major parties grows, Minnesota’s independents are increasingly seen as pivotal in statewide elections, particularly in determining the outcomes in competitive congressional districts.

Alaska: Unique Electoral Dynamics

Alaska’s political environment is uniquely suited to independents, thanks to its small population and distinctive electoral practices, like open primaries and ranked choice voting. A peek into the 2024 elections in Alaska also uncovers a large number of uncontested races throughout the state. 

These factors reduce the barriers typically faced by independent candidates in other states. 

Alaska also has a history of political independence, with figures like Senator Lisa Murkowski, who won her 2010 reelection as a write-in candidate, exemplifying the state's independent spirit. The flexibility of Alaska’s electorate means that independent candidates and voters will play a significant role in shaping the state’s political future.

Virginia: Suburban Shifts and Independent Voters

Virginia’s recent swing towards being a blue state is primarily driven by the changing demographics and political preferences of its suburban areas, particularly in Northern Virginia. 

However, independents here are becoming increasingly critical, as evidenced in gubernatorial and congressional elections where margins are often narrow. With both parties holding significant stakes in the state, the independent voters' sway in suburban districts is expected to be a deciding factor in upcoming elections.

Ohio: Uncontested Elections and Voter Dissatisfaction

Considering its history as a solid red state, Ohio seems an unlikely location for an indie surge. However, recent shenanigans in the Ohio legislature and unpopular policy positions could make this fertile ground for impact from independent voters and candidates alike. The state also has one of the highest rates of uncontested elections, with 84% of the 1405 current candidates running unopposed this election cycle. 

As you can see, the influence of independent voters and candidates in these states underscores a broader national trend towards a more nuanced political engagement, where allegiance to traditional party lines is waning. 

As the November 2024 elections draw near, the power of the independent vote cannot be underestimated. In states like Colorado, Maine, Arizona, and others, the impact of independents will be particularly pronounced, potentially altering the national political landscape.

Strategically Leveraging the Independent Movement in Key States and Nationwide

As independent voters and candidates grow in influence, there are strategic ways they can leverage this movement to shape electoral outcomes more effectively both in key states and across the nation. These strategies involve maximizing the impact of their votes, advocating for electoral reforms, and potentially altering the political landscape to foster greater inclusivity and representation.

It’s as easy as 1-2-3!

1: Effective Voting Strategies

One of the first things that needs to change if we want to change how we’re governed is the voting systems. 

Voters may not be able to get rid of such barriers as the Electoral College without a willing legislature, but there are still some things that put power into the hands of the people, including:

• Ranked Choice Voting (RCV): In states like Maine and Alaska where RCV is implemented, independents have a unique opportunity to express their preferences without the fear of "wasting" their vote. By ranking candidates, independents can support third-party and independent candidates without jeopardizing the chances of more viable candidates. This not only strengthens the position of independents but also encourages a more honest representation of voter preferences.

• Strategic Voting in Swing States: In swing states like Colorado and Arizona, where the vote can go either way, independents should focus on becoming more informed about the stances of all candidates, not just those from the major parties. By aligning their support strategically, independents can tip the balance in close races, ensuring that their issues and concerns are addressed by candidates seeking to win over the middle ground.

• Participation in Primaries: Many states allow independents to vote in primary elections without declaring party affiliation. By participating in these primaries, independents can influence the selection of candidates, potentially shifting party platforms to incorporate broader ideas that reflect the independent voters' views.

2: Advocacy for Electoral Reforms

In addition to utilizing our power at the ballot box, independent voters and candidates can push for fairness and change in how our elections are run. 

These measures include:

• Pushing for Open Primaries: Independents can advocate for open primaries nationwide, which would allow voters of any affiliation to participate in the primary election of their choice. This reform would increase the electoral influence of independents, enabling them to support candidates who best represent their views from the outset of the election cycle.

• Supporting Proportional Representation: Advocating for proportional representation can help ensure that legislative bodies more accurately reflect the spectrum of voter preferences, including those of independents. This can be particularly effective in states with a high number of legislative seats and where political diversity is stifled by winner-takes-all systems.

• Campaigning for Local Electoral Reforms: On a more localized level, independents can push for electoral reforms such as ranked choice voting and non-partisan ballots in city and county elections, setting precedents that could expand to higher levels of government.

3: Building a Nationwide Independent Network

True change starts locally and spreads nationally. Individuals, organizations, and independent candidates can make a difference by:

• Forming Coalitions: Independents can form coalitions to share resources, increase visibility, and coordinate on strategic voting efforts. These coalitions can also serve as platforms for advocating for policy changes and electoral reforms that benefit independents.

• Utilizing Social Media and Technology: By leveraging digital platforms, independents can enhance their reach and mobilize support more effectively. Social media campaigns can raise awareness about independent candidates and issues.

• Voter Education and Outreach: Educating the public about the importance of the independent vote and how it can influence policy outcomes is crucial. Workshops, seminars, and public speaking events can help independents articulate their positions on critical issues and advocate for a more inclusive political dialogue.

The strategic engagement of independent voters and candidates can significantly alter the political landscape and challenge the status quo nationwide. By voting strategically, advocating for electoral reforms, and building a supportive network, independents can ensure that their voices are heard and that they have a meaningful impact on the 2024 elections and beyond. 

This proactive approach not only enhances the power of independents, but also promotes a healthier democracy through increased voter engagement and representation.

Get Involved in Your State

The independent movement represents more than just a temporary shift. It signals a significant change in the American political paradigm. Independents are no longer just swing voters to be won over, but active participants shaping the future of democracy. 

As we move closer to the 2024 elections, all eyes will be on these states as barometers of this evolving dynamic. 

GoodParty.org is at the forefront of helping to usher in an independent revolution, but we can’t do it alone. Join our growing network as we strive to break the two-party stranglehold on our government — starting in your city and state, and continuing across the country!